• Welcome to PS6Forums - The #1 PlayStation Forum. Why not take a minute to register for your own free account now? Registration is completely free and will enable the use of all site features including the ability to join in or create your own discussions.

PS4 vs. Xbox One - The Ultimate Showdown!!!

Exclusives for a console are only worth it if you enjoy playing those genre of games. Stating one system has more or less exclusive titles is pointless. Kill Zone, IMO, is not worth owning over Halo. To each their own. The XB1 gives up nothing by having the additional features that the PS4 does not, so again, trying to justify that the PS4 is purely a gaming system is futile. If the PS4 were purely a gaming system there would be no Netflix, of Hulu, or the WWE (WTF?) channels you can download. IMO pointing out that the XB1 has these additional features sounds more like envy than anything else.

FWIW, I traded my XB1 for a PS4. Odds are I will probably pick up an XB1 again once Microsoft gets its act together with the arcade and indie games.
 
I disagree on trashing the Xbone for the TV part. It seems hypocritical for Sony fans as I loved the PS3 for it's games but also the fact it was the best BD player on the market at first. I honestly think all video game systems are going to have Streaming Movies/Netflix/etc and the ability to control the cable is not bad but it is not worth the extra $100 bucks originally priced different. The biggest mistake is Microsoft trying to force the Kinect down everyone's console when it has not improved any.

I am disappointed that Sony has no 3D TV Support in the PS4. It is not something I would use a lot but since the old PS3 had it, you certainly think the PS4 would have it.

I certainly think Sony is winning the war mainly because Microsoft tried to pull every underhanded trick in the book at release but to be honest, both consoles are underwhelming. Sony has released the worst Kilzone, the two worst Infamous games, and keeps releasing a bunch of 8 bit looking side scrollers and other similar games.

The people that held off on buying the PS4/Xbone were the smarter ones. I knew it would take time for good games but I didn't expect two months short of a year to have Fez to be one of the top two highest rated game on the console.

Sony, We need better games and I hope Naughty Dog and the final Uncharted is a system seller. Sony certainly has not won this war and to be honest, it is way too early and close to call who will win this generation. I know that both systems need better exclusives to win.


Or the smart ones looked at the games coming out and made an informed choice based on that and price?

No way is Shadow Fall worse than Killzone 3 not in a bazillion years mate and we get free DLC even now with extra co-op. Single player is one of the most drop dead gorgeous games you can play.

The Last Of Us is arguably THE game of the last generation.

Sony has won and everyone except a rabid MS fan would admit it after all your very own Major Nelson said first to sell 10 million wins the generation - so there you have it straight from one of your beloved Xbox leaders. :rofl
 
I had an original xbox and sold it because most all exclusives are on the PC and I have a rig that blows away both systems. These means exclusives are all that matters. I am not big into FPS and Killzone 4 was boring to me. The Infamous Second Son is the worst of Infamous titles and the $15 is not any better than the free vampire one on the PS3.

I am waiting for some good exclusives to come. And yes TLOU is one of my favorite games of all time but it really is just about the same on the PS4 and I finished it over a year ago twice so paying $50 bucks for the same game does not work for me.

I have no interest in Destiny as a multiplayer ony FPS.

The bottom line is the system still seems rushed to me. As for as game system goes, the PC wins hands down with the Sony in second play followed by Microsoft. The Wii IMO competes more with tablets and phones for non gamers. I do wish that Bayonetta 2 was coming to the PS4 as the original one was a fun game after a patch to make it playable on the PS3. Sony needs Naughty Dog to save the day. Also, anyone know what the first game Quantic Dreams will be releasing for the PS4?

Keep in mind that there have some been good games released on both consoles but when you can get wait two weeks and buy them on steam for half the price and get better graphics, it doesn't make sense to buy them on the consoles.

I still think Sony wins this generation because as usual, developers will find out how to get more out of the GPU and DDR5 RAM combo. The Xbone honestly takes Microsoft to write custom code just to get the Xbone to play a game in 1080p @ 60hz which is a bad sign for a console that should last through 2020 or more based on previous consoles.
 
PS4 is looking much nicer. Wish Forza would launch on PC or Even PS4 though.

Agree 100% but I think MS is keeping Forza for the Xbox platforms only. I honestly have grown tired of the racing Genre but would like to Play the newest Forza It just is not worth the cost of a xbone for me. I am sure MS will get greedy at some point and release it for the PC down the road.
 
Agree 100% but I think MS is keeping Forza for the Xbox platforms only. I honestly have grown tired of the racing Genre but would like to Play the newest Forza It just is not worth the cost of a xbone for me. I am sure MS will get greedy at some point and release it for the PC down the road.

Don't hold your breath for a PC release, as far as I know 1-4 never made it to the PC.

While a beautiful game F5 left me wanting more. The paint booth is the best it has ever been, which you can spend countless hours designing livery for your favorite car. This is one point that Forza has always had the advantage over GT. What pissed me off was that the DLC was for cars that I never had to pay for in the previous iterations of the game they are now wanting to charge. I refuse to pay for DLC cars, period. Turn 10 got the online community perfect if F4, and screwed it up in F5. Such a shame. Beautiful game that fell a bit short.
 
While a beautiful game F5 left me wanting more.


I don't have this game, but there was just a free to play weekend of it so I tried it. Sure the cars look great when "browsing", but when the races started I really was not wowed. It didn't look much better than any other car game I played as you have to "concentrate and play" and don't really see it like if your watching someone else play.
 
I've never been very impressed by the Xbox- I've always found the Playstation to be more refined and sophisticated. But nobody can deny that the Xbox has great graphics.
 
I've never been very impressed by the Xbox- I've always found the Playstation to be more refined and sophisticated. But nobody can deny that the Xbox has great graphics.

Have you checked out a mid to high end gaming rig the in the last 5 years? Most new games are the equivalent of playing the games on low detail for the PS4/Xbone. Now, with that said at least the console versions were designed to work with the exact specs of the console where the PC version quality depends on your rig and especially your CPU.

All systems have advantages and disadvantages. This is my preferred order:

1) PC Rig - You can get a $150 GPU that blows away the consoles. The PC costs more up front but is cheaper if you buy a lot of games thanks to steam and good quality games for $4 with the daily specials. The Big picture display allows me to hook it up to a HDTV and then just use remote desktop into it if I need to do update anything on the PC and easier than using a wireless keyboard and mouse in front of a PC.

2) PS4 -- Has best graphics capabilities now and it should get better in the future. However, the Sony Exclusives are the real reason this is the best console. I love Naughty Dog, Quantic Dreams, and normally Sucker Punch although I found Infamous 3 to be the weakest of the three.

3) Xbone -- This is a solid console but Microsoft screwed the pooch when they came out with DRM, no second hand games, no sharing, having a camera built in, and being $100 more for what is a inferior game system IMO. I don't trust the division of Microsoft that makes the Xboxes. The RROD on the 360 was ludicrous how many times it occurred. I have played Forza 4 but only seen Forza 5 via Youtube. It looks like a solid game but it has gone the route of what Sony did with Gran Turismo. It is more about paying for the cars. The PS2 version was the best version as it included all the cars and could watch HDTV looking replays even on the PS2 which I believe did 480p tops but man those replays looked good. I am also concerned that Microsoft wont change their policy on used games and such when they get enough sales. I would actually be fine with no used games if they did like Steam and would sell a $60 game for $40 three weeks after the release and down to $10 and under after a year.

Wii U - Nintendo makes very unique games and I would not mind playing the new Zelda but the one Tablet hookup was a bad choice. They should at least allow the opportunity to buy multi[;e ones because I think it could be nifty to have your own screen to call plays on sports games when playing someone else. However, Nintendo is producing hardware that is obsolete when it hits the market in terms of graphical power. And there is just so much Mario games a person can take. Mario Kart is old and motion controls are annoying to me these days. I think Nintendo would have been better to produce a console that was close to the PS4/Xbone and try not to make the console so casual. I honestly think that people should be able to use their tablets with games like PS4 (and I think Xbone) allows. I think Nintendo has turned into a niche product but I honestly think a good tablet is a better purchase than a Wii U.

Dean
 
Playstation 4 will be much better then x-box one think there will be better games on the playstation

I don't disagree with you, My only question is why did you think that? I am hoping people put reasoning with their posts as there are fanboys on either side that will just say PS4 kicks ass or Xbone Rules.

Tell me what games you think are better on the PS4 as compared to the Xbone?

I honestly think the Xbone exclusives just are not my type of games. I do not care about Forza but acknowledge it is a good game series. It has fallen into the Gran Turismo type pitfall where it is getting stale. The last Uncharted and maybe even a 2nd TLOU is pretty hard to deny as great games but TLOU is not for everyone.
 
Wii U - Nintendo makes very unique games and I would not mind playing the new Zelda but the one Tablet hookup was a bad choice. They should at least allow the opportunity to buy multi[;e ones because I think it could be nifty to have your own screen to call plays on sports games when playing someone else. However, Nintendo is producing hardware that is obsolete when it hits the market in terms of graphical power. And there is just so much Mario games a person can take. Mario Kart is old and motion controls are annoying to me these days. I think Nintendo would have been better to produce a console that was close to the PS4/Xbone and try not to make the console so casual. I honestly think that people should be able to use their tablets with games like PS4 (and I think Xbone) allows. I think Nintendo has turned into a niche product but I honestly think a good tablet is a better purchase than a Wii U.

Having the ability to hook-up another Game Pad is, evidently, coming in the future. Nintendo and the Wii U have the same amount of titles, if not more, in 1080p than the Xbone or PS4--now of course resolution has nothing to do with graphical output, but it is something to keep in mind. Mario Kart 8 is fresh as life and doesn't require motion controls--nor do most of the Wii U games. Nor is the console marketed as a casual gaming rig. Have you seen the games coming to the system? People need to start putting aside their predispositions about Nintendo and get their heads out their bumbums; it is starting to get absurd.

Also here is a comparison chart of the system specs: http://www.ign.com/wikis/xbox-one/PS4_vs._Xbox_One_vs._Wii_U_Comparison_Chart

Obviously the system doesn't compare but it does not need to, contra to gamer ideology.
 
We have two PS4's and a Wii U here. I kind of want an XboxOne. I might toss around the idea of one for my birthday next month and see if anyone bites lol
 
Anyone who knows hardware knows there is no comparison from a graphical standpoint between PS4 and Wii U. Wii U has the sane amount of 1080p games but was released a year ahead of the PS4.

Nintendo fans have to be excited about Mario XXXXXX because they never know if third party games will make the port to the Wii U and it is a big deal as they have to really port the game. The PS4/Xbone conversion is easy. The conversion to a machine that has such limited power in this timeframe will become bigger by the day.

You say there is going to be a future upgrade to add a 2nd Wii "Tablet" to it. How much does that cost and how much money are you spending for a 2nd controller when at least the first two years of games wont support it.

Nintendo always does it own things and they did well with a different approach grabbing casual gamers with the Wii and if they would have made a console on equal status spec wise with the PS4/Xbone then it would be competition.

I could be wrong but the Wii U has been deemed a failure by about everyone. It is a casual gaming system which will have all the typical Nintendo games remade for the 20th iteration but I still think the lack of power under the hood has doomed them.

Nintendo will always sell to a crowd that loves Nintendo games and it is something you will not get with other consoles but the fact that their are so many casual games for phones and tablets makes it hard to justify a Wii U unless they are just huge Nintendo game fans.

I honestly thing Nintendo will end up going the way of Sega and selling their games to all consoles in the future or team up across the street with Microsoft and create a joint console that would scare Sony to death.

I have nothing against the Wii U other than outside The Legend of Zelda, I really find Nintendo games to be repetitive and boring. I think you will see bigger differences between the games in about 3 years when developers have figured out how to get more power out of the PS4 and possibly Xbone.

For you folks that own all the consoles, I don't see why you would even be in this discussion.
 
We have two PS4's and a Wii U here. I kind of want an XboxOne. I might toss around the idea of one for my birthday next month and see if anyone bites lol

I have to admit something, a certain Super-Mod might of purchased a Xbox One yesterday...
 
I have to admit something, a certain Super-Mod might of purchased a Xbox One yesterday...

Was it you? :P

We usually get all three consoles here. But Microsoft's 2013 E3 conference changed my mind -and now we have 2 PS4's lol

As for the Wii U? We all fiddled with it when Mario Kart came out, but that's about it. before that? I played Lego City back in March or May of 2013, so I went over a year without touching that big goofy looking gamepad lol I sort of feel sorry for Nintendo at this point.
 
I am a firm believer in a moderate to high end PC Rig is your best choice. When you get into having both a PS4 and Xbone and buy some games and accessories then you are in the good PC Right money. I personally have a PC Right and then a PS4. The PS4 is the best console choice for me because a lot of exclusives and previous exclusives are on the PC from Microsoft and the PS4 has exclusives that no one else has that I really like. I really enjoyed The Witcher (Yes the next version is coming to the PS4), Alan Wake, and may buy the new HD version of the original Fable for the PC.

There is no way I could play The Las of US, Uncharted 1-IV without the Playstation and Heavy Rain which were my favorite games of the generation. Right now, Diablo III might be my favorite game for the PS4 but I own the PC version. Even Ultimate Survival Edition of Lara Craft looked much better on the PC than it does on the PS4/Xbone and it cost me $5 bucks on Steam.

I am glad to pay $60 for quality games but Watchdogs was not worth it and I wish I would have waited a few weeks and bought it for the PC for half price. It is not aa bad game. It is just not as good as advertised and the graphics they originally showed at E3 were completely different.
 
Was it you? :P

We usually get all three consoles here. But Microsoft's 2013 E3 conference changed my mind -and now we have 2 PS4's lol

As for the Wii U? We all fiddled with it when Mario Kart came out, but that's about it. before that? I played Lego City back in March or May of 2013, so I went over a year without touching that big goofy looking gamepad lol I sort of feel sorry for Nintendo at this point.

I wouldn't say goofy.. I played with it a bunch at the store and it felt nice in hand.
 

Get Connected With PS6Forums.com

Like PS6 Forums!

Advertisements

Back
Top